ProphetX CEO Dean Sisun
3–4 minutes

ProphetX urges CFTC to block sportsbook economics on exchanges

ProphetX co-founder and CEO Dean Sisun has asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to protect peer-to-peer trading as the agency actively develops clearer prediction market rules.

In an August 20 letter addressed to Michael Passalacqua, Designated Federal Officer of the Innovation Advisory Committee (IAC), Sisun said federal rules should prevent sports exchanges from adopting traditional sportsbook economics. The request coincided with the IAC’s inaugural meeting on prediction markets and event contracts.

As a peer-to-peer exchange, ProphetX matches customers with other customers and does not take a directional position on an outcome. A sportsbook, on the other hand, typically sets odds, accepts wagers on both sides, and carries the resulting financial exposure.

Sisun said: “A two-sided, peer-to-peer exchange model operating under durable federal oversight is not simply another way to package the state sportsbook model. It is a structurally distinct, more consumer-favorable way to bring regulated sports event contracts into the financial system.”

According to Sisun, that distinction should remain central to the Commission’s policy work, and he asked the Commission to preserve price formation among buyers and sellers on designated contract markets. The letter also addressed affiliated market makers, trading firms with ownership ties to the exchange itself, as opposed to independent firms with no stake in the venue.

Defining the role of affiliated market makers

Sisun warned that if an affiliate becomes an exchange’s dominant or sole source of liquidity, the venue risks re-creating the same single-dealer dynamic as a sportsbook, just under an exchange label.

“Affiliated liquidity may help support or bootstrap a market, but it should supplement rather than displace independent price formation,” Sisus wrote. “For sports event markets, rules should preserve room for customers, professional market makers, and other independent participants to compete on both sides of the market while the venue remains neutral as to outcome.”

He urged the CFTC to draw a clear line between bona fide market making, quoting both sides of a market without a view on the outcome, and directional proprietary trading, where a firm bets its own capital on which side wins.

The letter further sought a conditions-based framework under Section 4(c) of the Commodity Exchange Act, which would set objective requirements for eligible sports contracts, including settlement terms, surveillance, and information controls. Sisun said that approach would give exchanges greater certainty before listing contracts by avoiding a separate, case-by-case Rule 40.11 public-interest review for each product.

CFTC ready to strengthen prediction markets oversight

The proposal arrived as the advisory committee revealed sharp divides over event contract regulation. During the August 20 meeting, CME Group CEO Terry Duffy questioned whether self-certification has allowed certain products to reach the market too quickly. He also warned that some contracts could be vulnerable to manipulation or trading based on nonpublic information.

Selig disputed examples cited by Duffy, which related to insider trading incidents at Polymarket’s unregulated global site. Selig emphasized that those contracts were offered offshore, not on a US-regulated exchange. Selig also told the committee that the CFTC would soon propose amendments to Parts 38 and 40.

Those changes would update listing rules for event contracts and add consumer-protection requirements. They would cover product governance, market design and incentive programs, he said.

Proposed rules address public interest concerns

The Commission has already proposed revisions to Rule 40.11 through its Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPR), which covers event contracts involving sensitive public-interest concerns. The proposed amendments would define key terms and set out factors for assessing public-interest questions.

The CFTC has also proposed tailored data-reporting requirements for fully collateralized event contracts.

The rulemaking comes amid state challenges to federally regulated sports contracts, which critics describe as unlawful sports betting. The CFTC maintains that the Commodity Exchange Act gives it exclusive jurisdiction over those products.

Sisun’s letter focuses on a narrower question: whether federal rules preserve a neutral venue when market makers are affiliated with an exchange.