Exterior of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission building
7–11 minutes

CFTC innovation council clashes over prediction markets overhaul

Mike Selig, Chair of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), told the regulator’s new innovation council on August 20 that “we’ve heard the concerns of the public loud and clear” about the inadequacy of existing consumer protection rules for retail prediction market traders. He also pledged a fresh round of amendments to parts 38 and 40 of CFTC regulations to fix them.

The Innovation Advisory Committee’s (IAC) inaugural meeting brought together prediction market operators, exchange executives and some of the industry’s fiercest critics. The conversation at times turned openly hostile, including a heated exchange between CME Group CEO Terry Duffy and Kalshi co-founder Luana Lopes Lara over market manipulation. Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong used the session to float a three-part test for deciding which markets regulators should allow at all, a proposal that could shape how the CFTC handles contentious “mention markets” going forward.

Participants clashed over manipulation risk, inconsistent KYC rules across trading channels, and the escalating state-versus-federal turf war, with Selig closing by calling out two of the industry’s most vocal state-level critics.

Market manipulation takes center stage

Insider trading and potential market manipulation is a key issue that the sector needs to untangle, and indeed has tried to untangle through loudly-promoted and demonstratively proprietary technological solutions. It was this topic that instigated the most ill-tempered exchange of the day between a triumvirate of Duffy, Chair Selig and Lopes Lara. 

Duffy pointed to insider trading tied to the Maduro capture and the Trump teleprompter market as his examples.

Selig abruptly intervened to call fake news on Duffy’s examples, as the markets in question were listed on Polymarket’s international platform rather than on a US-regulated exchange. An argument later broke out as Lopes Lara asked whether CME Group had itself ever experienced any market manipulation issues in its history, with the CME boss responding by stating that his company employed more staff in its regulatory department than Kalshi does in its entire company.

There were plenty of constructive comments on the topic as well:

Terry Duffy: “There’s been 2,500 self-certifications since this administration has taken office in January of 2025 of which none have been opposed. And there’s been a lot of self-certifications around products that are in violation of Core Principle 3, which is susceptible to manipulation. There’s no doubt about it.”

Luana Lopes Lara: “Every market has risk and every nascent market will have risks as well…and there have been issues in every single traditional market, in every single exchange, here onshore and offshore. And I think the point of having regulation is that you find these issues, you address these issues.”

Shayne Coplan, Polymarket founder and CEO: “It’s the least anonymous financial market of all time. You can look at every single market and see every single trade and look at the trading history in full of every single participant. It’s a level of transparency that’s unprecedented.”

On consumer protections in prediction markets

Selig’s pledge to tighten retail protections found broad support, though panelists differed on how far federal minimum standards alone can go in protecting vulnerable customers.

Chair Mike Selig: “We’ve heard the concerns of the public loud and clear regarding the inadequacy of our existing consumer protection requirements for retail. These amendments would also establish clear expectations for product governance, market design, and incentive programs.”

Matt King, Fanatics Betting and Gaming CEO: “While a vast majority of customers will use these products for profit or for fun, there is a small chunk of them that will have a problem using them. And I think it’s really important that we set minimum standards for all operators in the industry in order to ensure that we protect customers, but you ultimately avoid the backlash that would be inevitable from a lot of negative stories coming out where people have used any of the platforms in this industry to their own financial harm.”

Luana Lopes Lara: “I’ve never heard a single argument on why state-by-state has better consumer protection than a federal framework. If you go state by state, you see that very few states actually have any regulation against advertising to minors or any regulation against advertising to self-excluded [users].”

On differing KYC requirements for DCMs vs FCMs

In one of the day’s rare moments of agreement, Tenev and Robins both argued there’s no principled reason to hold direct-to-exchange customers to different verification standards than those routed through a broker.

Vlad Tenev, Robinhood CEO: “Some people actually prefer to use direct DCM models because they don’t collect their employer information […] There shouldn’t be this implicit arbitrage – whether you’re a retail customer coming from FCM versus direct to DCM, I think KYC requirements should be uniform.”

Jason Robins, DraftKings CEO: “The rules for customers going directly to DCM versus those going through an FCM should be identical. There really is no distinction from the consumer protection perspective. So that absolutely should be the case.”

On which markets should be listed

Panelists broadly agreed mention markets pose the sharpest manipulation risk, but are split on where to draw the line.

Vlad Tenev: “Certain mention markets I think are very prone to manipulation. And I don’t think that it’s necessarily even conscious or intentional, but if it’s someone giving an informal speech, you’ll just see people at these events saying, ‘Hey, say this, say that.’ You never really know whether you’re giving someone a thumbs up because they have a financial interest in the outcome or whether it’s something more innocent.”

Don Wilson, DRW founder and CEO: “The question of, will George Santos attend the State of the Union address, I don’t think that that was really all that important to anybody. And it was obviously readily subject to manipulation by one person, with no impact on his life really — and of course he took advantage of that.”

Professor Harry Crane, Professor of Statistics and Affiliated Faculty in the Graduate Program in Philosophy at Rutgers University: “War, terrorism, assassination, gaming – it’s very important to get clarity on what these terms actually mean. […] These are also the topics that are among the most important and potentially the most useful and valuable from both a financial and an information standpoint. […] I think actually the sensitivities only emphasize the need for innovation rather than prohibition.”

On the state vs. federal argument

Most speakers converged on federal preemption as the only workable path, though Donohue cautioned that unresolved questions over securities status leave real litigation risk regardless of which level of government regulates.

Vlad Tenev: “A lot of the criticism, no doubt, from the states and other actors are folks that have a financial interest in the opposite rather than a principled interest. And principled arguments about a federal framework not being sufficient for surveillance or customer protection just doesn’t make sense on its face.”

Craig Donohue, Cboe Global Markets CEO: “When you have securities products that are unregistered trading on a DCM, no matter what the regulators want to do, at some point there’s going to be litigation. At some point there’ll be rescission exercised by customers on those platforms at the state level or at the federal level because they can do it both ways. And those are risks that don’t promote safety and soundness.”

Luana Lopes Lara: “A lot of these lawsuits are actually becoming very dangerous because of how broad they are. If you look at New York, for example, they’re not just about sports. They’re not just about prediction markets. A lot of companies here that actually never touch prediction markets could be interpreted to being under a lot of what New York state is trying to make happen.”

Brian Armstrong’s proposal

In a potentially significant intervention towards the end of the action, Coinbase’s Armstrong laid out a proposal for a three-point test to decide which markets ought to be permissible.

Test one is whether a market creates public harm: “You could say does it create public good, but I think we should by default allow it to happen unless we can point to harm.”

Test two is can you establish a direct causal link to that harm: “If you don’t enforce that, almost anything could have an indirect link. Imagine any of us stepping down as CEO and the stock price falling that day. If you go to that extreme of saying there can’t be any second or third order effect of harm, then we wouldn’t even have public stock markets.”

And test three is how subject to manipulation it is: “But we have to be careful not to go too far with this because there could be examples where public good outweighs risk of it being subject to manipulation. […] President Trump making a comment about the tariffs in Canada – that’s a mention market. It’s by one person. One could say it’s even subject to manipulation, but to me the public good of that outweighs the downside.”

Fighting talk from Selig

The headline admission that the current rules framework is insufficient to protect retail traders engaging in prediction market trading was one of the most substantial comments made at the meeting, but there was also fighting talk from the CFTC chief.

Defending the CFTC’s exclusive right to regulate all of the businesses represented in the room, he quoted one of his predecessors, saying: “State actors are sadly suffering from what the late CFTC chairman Philip McBride Johnson called NFS or Name Fixation Syndrome, an intellectual malady that causes the listener to hear only the first part of a phrase. Without treatment this can lead the patient to think that the futures should be regulated by the same agency that supervises the name. The consequences, of course, are preposterous.”

And closing out the council meeting Selig took the opportunity to call out Attorney General of New York Letitia James and former Governor of New Jersey Chris Christie, two figures vocally antagonistic towards prediction markets.

There was a lot of gratitude expressed by participants for the CFTC’s aggressive stance in the face of state challenges, and judging by Selig’s comments, there isn’t likely to be any quarter given any time soon.