US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in Richmond, VA with clear blue skies.
6–9 minutes

Kalshi loses 2-1 in Fourth Circuit as judges split on reasoning

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on Nov. 17 became the third of four federal appeals courts to rule against Kalshi in its preliminary-injunction fights with state gaming regulators. The Third Circuit remains the only one so far to side with the prediction market exchange.

A divided panel upheld a lower court’s decision denying Kalshi a preliminary injunction, which would have blocked Maryland from enforcing its sports-wagering laws against the exchange’s sports-event contracts while its lawsuit proceeds. Judge Roger Gregory concurred, Judge Stephanie Thacker concurred but on different grounds, and Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented.

“Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong,” Elisabeth Diana, Head of Communications at Kalshi, told NEXTPredict.io. “This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.” 

The decision is not a final ruling on whether Maryland’s gambling laws apply to Kalshi. The appeal addressed the narrower question of whether Kalshi had shown it was likely to succeed on its claim that federal law preempts those laws. US District Judge Adam Abelson found in August 2025 that it had not.

Kalshi also lost its Nevada appeal at the Ninth Circuit in August, and the Sixth Circuit ruled for the states in Ohio and Tennessee in September.

Unlike the unanimous Ninth and Sixth Circuit panels, the two judges in the Maryland case who agreed on the outcome split on the reasoning. That leaves open both whether Kalshi’s contracts are swaps and whether federal law preempts state gambling law. It also adds to the disagreement the Supreme Court has been asked to resolve.

Gregory: Congress hasn’t been clear

Gregory’s concurrence in the Nov. 17 opinion turns on preemption, not the swap definition.

According to Gregory, the Commodity Exchange Act’s (CEA) grant of exclusive jurisdiction sits in unresolved tension with the statute’s Special Rule on gaming contracts and with CFTC Rule 40.11.

“Congress also enacted a separate provision elsewhere in the same Act providing separate treatment for certain event contracts specifically involving gaming, among other things, and providing that certain such contracts may not be listed or traded on a DCM.”

“The question here is whether, when read together, those provisions clearly establish that the CFTC’s authority over the sports event contracts at issue excludes Maryland’s traditionally recognized authority to enforce its gaming laws.”

Gregory said he doesn’t decide the swap question because “…even assuming they are, neither the Act nor the CFTC’s implementation of it clearly establish that such contracts are entitled to trade on a DCM free from state gaming laws.”

The opinion noted that Kalshi’s sports contracts trade because the company self-certified them and the CFTC has not ordered them removed. In his view, this alone does not exempt them from state law.

“Nothing in the CEA or the CFTC’s regulations converts agency inaction into a determination carrying sweeping preemptive consequences,” he wrote.

He also rejected conflict preemption, saying Kalshi can comply with both regimes by getting a Maryland license or by not offering the contracts in the state.

“Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so,” Gregory wrote. “Here, it has not done so with the clarity our precedents require.”

“What is happening here is sports betting”

Unlike Gregory, Thacker decided the case on the swap definition. The CEA covers contracts whose payment depends on “the occurrence, nonoccurrence, or the extent of the occurrence of an event.” Kalshi’s sports contracts, she wrote, pay out on a game’s result, not on whether the game happens.

“But the outcome of an event is not the occurrence of the event,” Thacker wrote. She called the dictionary definition of “event” as “outcome,” on which Kalshi relied, “archaic.” She also warned that Kalshi’s reading “would criminalize any sports bet placed in the United States — from Las Vegas casinos to local pool halls,” because the CEA bars retail customers from trading swaps off an exchange.

She pointed to Kalshi’s past marketing as a sports betting platform, which Kalshi’s counsel acknowledged at oral argument. Asked why the company dropped that language, counsel said it had “caused the very confusion” raised in briefs against Kalshi.

“I, for one, am not confused. What is happening here is sports betting,” Thacker wrote. “That is gambling, plain and simple.”

A dissent on Kalshi’s side, with limits

Benjamin held that Kalshi’s sports contracts are swaps and that the CEA preempts Maryland’s laws as applied to them. She would have vacated the district court’s ruling and sent the case back for the judge to weigh the other injunction factors. She called Thacker’s distinction between an event and its outcome an “artificially” narrow reading of the statute. Benjamin relied heavily on the Third Circuit majority in KalshiEX v. Flaherty.

“The common criticism of Kalshi’s platform—that it walks like a casino, swims like a casino, and quacks like a casino, and thus should be regulated like a casino—appears logical. But that’s not what Congress said. Rather, ‘exclusive jurisdiction’ belongs to the CFTC,” Benjamin wrote. “Just because the CFTC hasn’t disapproved Kalshi’s sports-related contracts under its regulations, doesn’t mean Maryland can regulate Kalshi in its place.”

Even under her reading, not all of Kalshi’s sports contracts would count as swaps. Benjamin agreed with Maryland that the swap definition needs a “limiting principle.” Under her approach, contracts on game results, season outcomes or the Super Bowl qualify as swaps because businesses can use them to hedge. Parlays and prop bets “would not fall under the definition because they could not reasonably be used to hedge, have no independent economic consequence, and are better understood as pure speculation.”

How we got here

On April 7, 2025, Maryland’s gaming regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter. The letter said Kalshi was unlawfully offering “wagering on sporting events” without a state license and gave it 15 days to stop. Kalshi sued in federal court in Maryland on April 21, 2025.

Abelson denied the injunction on Aug. 1, 2025. It was Kalshi’s first loss after early preliminary injunction wins in Nevada and New Jersey. Kalshi appealed, and on Aug. 13, 2025, Maryland agreed to hold off enforcement until the Fourth Circuit ruled. The panel heard oral arguments on May 7, 2026.

In October, Kalshi pointed the panel to the CFTC’s Oct. 9 rulemakings, including a proposal to define sports, political and other event contracts as swaps. Maryland responded with the Sixth Circuit’s decision, according to the docket. None of the three opinions mentions the October proposals.

What comes next

Kalshi seized on the panel’s division, saying in a statement that the decision “demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets,” per Reuters.

Maryland read it differently. Jeremy Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission, said the ruling “affirmed the state’s ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering.”

With another appellate ruling filed, a number of next moves and deadlines are in play.

Possible rehearing request

Kalshi has until Dec. 1 to ask the panel or the full Fourth Circuit to rehear the case, under the 14-day deadline in the federal appellate rules. That route has not worked for Kalshi so far. The Ninth Circuit denied Kalshi rehearing on Nov. 4, and no judge requested an en banc vote. That denial gives Kalshi until early February to petition the Supreme Court in the Nevada case. Kalshi has also asked the full Sixth Circuit to rehear its Ohio and Tennessee loss.

Maryland enforcement potential

Maryland agreed to hold off enforcement only until the Fourth Circuit ruled. Tuesday’s judgement clears the way for enforcement action. Baker’s statement signals the commission intends to use that authority. The underlying lawsuit, which so far has been fought only over preliminary relief, returns to Abelson.

Supreme Court draws closer

Three petitions are pending before the justices. They are New Jersey’s request that the Supreme Court settle the Kalshi sports fight, and petitions from Robinhood Derivatives and Crypto.com’s exchange against Nevada. Responses in all three are due Dec. 7.

CFTC rulemaking looms

The comment period on the agency’s proposal to write sports and other event contracts into the swap definition closes Nov. 18. Gregory’s concurrence gives the agency’s rulemaking more weight than the other opinions do.

He cited the CFTC’s still-pending June proposal to amend Rule 40.11 as evidence the framework is unsettled. He framed his conclusion as holding “until Congress and the CFTC are clear.” Thacker’s reading rests on the statute’s text alone, so agency action would not change it.

Four federal appeals courts have now ruled on Kalshi’s bids to stop states from enforcing their gambling laws while its lawsuits proceed. Three ruled against and one in favor, with judges divided over why. For now, whether a state can police Kalshi’s sports contracts depends on which circuit it sits in, and that is the split the Supreme Court has been asked to resolve.

NEXTPredict.io has requested comment from Kalshi and will update the story with any comment received.