Kalshi and National Council on Problem Gambling logos over a blurred prediction-market trading interface.
5–8 minutes

NCPG says Kalshi funding has not changed prediction-market stance

The National Council on Problem Gambling says its $2m relationship with Kalshi has not changed its stance on prediction markets, even as the partnership continues to draw criticism and has contributed to several organizations cutting ties with the nonprofit.

“NCPG maintains a strong firewall between its donors and its work,” director of public affairs Cait Huble told NEXTPredict.io. “Financial support does not provide any donor or member with influence over NCPG’s positions or priorities. Those are guided by our mission, subject-matter expertise, and the evidence around gambling-related harm.”

NCPG is also seeing direct signs that prediction markets are causing problems for some users. Huble said people have begun contacting the National Problem Gambling Helpline for help with issues tied to prediction markets.

The comments come a week after NCPG reiterated that it considers purchasing event contracts “functionally gambling” and called for safeguards including self-exclusion, age verification, risk disclosures and direct access to help.

That position has remained intact since before Kalshi became NCPG’s first Financial Services & Trading member in May and committed $2 million over two years to support the organization’s work. The relationship has nevertheless become a flashpoint, with regulators, affiliates and other organizations questioning whether accepting funding from a prediction market operator is compatible with NCPG’s mission.

NCPG says its position ‘has not changed’

NCPG says its latest warning on prediction markets reflects the same position it held before Kalshi joined the organization. Huble pointed to the group’s comment on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s proposed rules for event contract derivatives as evidence of that continuity.

“NCPG’s position has not changed,” Huble said. “In April, NCPG submitted public comment to the CFTC, stating that purchasing event contracts is functionally gambling and carries the potential for gambling-related harm.”

She said the continued growth and accessibility of prediction markets has made it increasingly important for consumer safeguards and resources to keep pace.

Kalshi, however, does not agree with NCPG’s characterization of the products. Responding to the organization’s Sept. 22 statement, a Kalshi spokesperson told Axios that the exchange has “industry-leading consumer protections and resources for traders” and said, “while we disagree with the NCPG on their assessment, we welcome the dialogue.”

Huble said that disagreement does not prevent the two organizations from working together.

“NCPG’s neutrality allows us to work collaboratively with a broad range of stakeholders without requiring agreement on every issue,” she said. “Differing perspectives do not prevent meaningful collaboration in areas where there is common ground, particularly around safeguards, consumer education, and reducing harm.”

Prediction-market problems reaching national helpline

NCPG says its concerns are not limited to the possibility of future harm. The organization is now hearing directly from people seeking help with problems involving event contract trading.

“We are seeing evidence of harm from multiple sources,” Huble said. “The National Problem Gambling Helpline (1-800-MY-RESET) is receiving contacts related to prediction markets, providing a direct indication that people are experiencing negative consequences.”

Huble said NCPG is also watching research suggesting that gambling and other high-risk financial activities are increasingly being viewed as ways to invest or build wealth rather than strictly as entertainment.

“These indicators reinforce what we are seeing in practice: the harm is not theoretical; people are experiencing it today,” Huble said.

The Sept. 22 statement, written by NCPG board president Derek Longmeier, similarly warned that the rapid growth of prediction markets has outpaced the consumer protections surrounding them, particularly as the products become more widely available to younger adults and other new users.

Platforms expand responsible-trading safeguards

Prediction-market operators have increasingly added tools intended to address some of the risks NCPG has raised.

Kalshi has built out a broader responsible-trading program that includes trading breaks and personalized funding caps, along with access to support through Birches Health and a dedicated responsible trading hub. 

In May, it added a “Health Check” system that looks for signs of potentially unhealthy trading activity and can recommend personalized deposit limits. The platform also added an “Inner Circle” feature that allows users to give friends or family visibility into their trading activity.

The exchange has also partnered with IC360 to integrate a cross-platform self-exclusion tool designed to allow users to block themselves from participating on multiple prediction-market platforms.

Other operators have moved in the same direction. Novig has made responsible trading a central part of its positioning, adopting a 21-and-over age requirement alongside deposit and loss limits, cooling-off periods and self-exclusion tools.

Sportsbook-linked prediction-market platforms have adopted similar safeguards. DraftKings has extended its responsible-gaming framework to its prediction-market business, including user education, deposit limits and self-exclusion tools. FanDuel Predicts also offers responsible-trading protections including deposit limits, alerts and self-exclusion.

NCPG said in its Sept. 22 statement that many of those safeguards should be considered a baseline for prediction-market platforms, alongside clear risk disclosures and direct access to problem-gambling resources.

Kalshi relationship has driven member departures

The Kalshi relationship has had clear consequences for NCPG. Several organizations have cut ties with the nonprofit after objecting to its decision to accept Kalshi as a member and financial supporter.

The Michigan Gaming Control Board and Ohio Casino Control Commission both withdrew from NCPG while citing concerns about the Kalshi arrangement. The Ohio withdrawal was detailed in Sept. 10 Massachusetts Gaming Commission meeting materials reviewing the controversy. Massachusetts regulators also considered leaving NCPG but ultimately voted to remain members for now.

Washington’s Evergreen Council on Problem Gambling has also left the organization, citing in a Sept. 16 letter “unresolved” concerns about the Kalshi agreement, as well as broader questions about NCPG’s governance, transparency and handling of affiliate concerns.

Gaming supplier Aristocrat, meanwhile, said it was “stepping back” from NCPG because of the organization’s “acceptance of substantial funding” from a “prediction-market-based sports gambling platform in contravention of state and tribal gaming regulations.”

Asked how concerned NCPG is about the departures, Huble said the organization takes the criticism seriously.

“NCPG values the perspectives of our members and affiliates, including when they disagree with the organization’s approach, and we take those concerns seriously,” she said. “That feedback is important to the organization, alongside our responsibility to focus NCPG’s work where it can have the greatest impact in mitigating gambling-related harm and advancing the work at the core of our mission.”

Leadership exits fuel broader Kalshi speculation

The controversy has also coincided with significant leadership turnover at NCPG, fueling speculation that the Kalshi relationship is behind turmoil within the organization. But the reasons for those departures are less clear.

Executive director Heather Maurer announced her resignation recently after less than a year in the role; she had started Jan. 7. NCPG director of programs Jaime Costello also recently announced that she had resigned from her role.

No reason has been given publicly for Maurer’s resignation. Costello later clarified that her own departure was related to “workplace culture and my own values.”

“I’m not taking a side on the Kalshi donation, and I’m not looking to be part of any effort against NCPG,” Costello added.

NCPG says Kalshi controversy has not changed its approach

Kalshi’s membership has demonstrably prompted some organizations to leave NCPG, but there is no public evidence tying every recent personnel change at the nonprofit to the partnership.

For its part, NCPG maintains that the controversy has not altered how it approaches prediction markets or other contributors.

“That standard applies equally to every organization that contributes to NCPG,” Huble said of the group’s separation between financial support and its policy positions.