As prediction markets expand across the US, affiliates are looking to capitalize on a new audience and a growing range of event contracts, while the regulatory framework is still taking shape. Catena Media and Better Collective are both building out prediction market businesses, even though affiliates currently earn less per customer than they do from sportsbooks.
NEXTPredict.io spoke to Manuel Stan, CEO of Catena Media, and Karl Pugh, senior vice president of revenue at Better Collective, about where affiliates fit into the prediction market ecosystem. Stan described prediction markets as “the most significant growth opportunity in the sports space right now.” Catena is adding them as a new vertical across its existing brands and building a dedicated brand, PlayPicks.com. Pugh said the category could become “a meaningful additional revenue stream alongside traditional sports betting and casino.”
Both said the economics differ from those of their traditional markets. In the US, affiliates are most commonly paid on a cost-per-acquisition (CPA) basis rather than revenue share, receiving a fee once a referred user makes their first deposit. For prediction markets, Stan said, those CPA levels are currently lower than in sports betting or casino.
Regulatory uncertainty also continues to influence the market. Platforms regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) are available in states yet to regulate online sports betting, which gives affiliates a source of customer acquisition that doesn’t require “traditional” betting to be legalized. Several state regulators dispute event contracts’ legal standing. Stan said the vertical will need regulatory clarity, commercial terms that reflect the value of the user and a full season of data before it goes mainstream.
Capitalizing on the ‘significant growth opportunity for affiliates’
Stan highlights three key reasons for why prediction markets are the biggest growth opportunity in sports right now.
“The first is geographic reach,” Stan said. “Because they are federally regulated, they reach audiences in states where sports betting isn’t regulated at all.”
The second reason he gives is product scope, which stretches further than sports markets.
“Contracts go well beyond sports into politics, entertainment, and financial markets, reaching people who aren’t primarily sports fans.
“Thirdly, we look at demographics. As the eligibility age is 18 rather than 21, which is the case for sportsbooks, this opens up a younger audience that a sportsbook simply can’t reach.”
For Catena specifically, Stan said the company is taking two distinct approaches. The first is to add prediction markets as a new vertical across its existing brands, so it sits naturally alongside the sports content its audiences already use. The second is a dedicated new brand, PlayPicks.com, built from the ground up and focused entirely on prediction markets.
Pugh echoed Stan’s view that prediction markets have the potential to become a “significant new vertical for affiliates,” particularly in the US.
“What makes the opportunity interesting is that it is not simply another way of trading on sports,” he said. “The range of markets is much broader, which opens up new audiences, content opportunities and commercial partnerships.
“We are still relatively early in the development of the category, but the traction we have seen so far gives us confidence that this can become a meaningful additional revenue stream alongside traditional sports betting and casino.”
How can affiliates succeed in prediction markets?
Stan and Pugh also have similar thoughts on the difference between this sector and their traditional markets. Pugh said affiliates cannot simply take a traditional sportsbook affiliate model, change the operator names and expect it to work. He said not only are the products different, but the potential audience is broader and people engage with prediction markets in different ways.
“Affiliates need to understand what users actually want to trade on and then build content and products around that behavior,” Pugh said. “It also requires speed. This is a category developing very quickly, so the ability to experiment, learn from the data and adapt is going to be a real competitive advantage.”
Building on this, Stan said the affiliates best placed to capitalize on opportunities in the sector are those with strong sports products, because that is what drives most of the new depositing customer volume. He added that “everything else follows from that.”
“The content is also different work,” he said. “A contract on an outcome is not a betting line, so the comparison logic, the explanations and the user education all have to be rebuilt rather than reskinned. Distribution changes too since state-level pages have been the backbone of US sports content for eight years, and a product whose availability is drawn on a different map does not fit that structure.
“Compliance is the part most likely to be underestimated,” said Stan. “These venues sit under a different regulatory framework from state-licensed sportsbooks, so nothing about affiliate licensing, disclosure or responsible gambling practice transfers across automatically.”
Commercial models are still ‘developing’
The need to adapt comes as affiliates and operators continue to work out exactly how the commercial relationship around prediction markets should look. While the fundamentals of customer acquisition remain familiar, both Pugh and Stan said that the economics of the emerging vertical differ from those of traditional sports betting and casino.
“The fundamentals are familiar,” Pugh said. “Operators want high-quality customers and affiliates with strong audiences can help them acquire those customers efficiently. But it is a newer ecosystem, so the commercial models are still developing.
“For us, the interesting part is that prediction markets are largely incremental. They bring new partners and potentially new audiences into the ecosystem, while allowing affiliates to leverage capabilities in content, user acquisition and conversion that we have spent years building.”
Stan said prediction markets follow the same CPA model, but explained why the rates differ.
“Where it differs is the level of CPA, which is currently lower than what we see in sports betting or casino,” he said. “There are two main reasons for that. The first is how operators make money: they earn from trading activity rather than from the hold on a betting line. The second is that competition is still limited, with relatively few operators in the market today.”
But he expects that second part to change.
“We expect CPA levels to rise as operators gather more data and can better estimate the long-term value of the customers, and, just as importantly, as more competitors enter the market.”
What needs to happen for prediction markets to go mainstream in the affiliate space?
With affiliates increasingly exploring prediction markets as a new source of customers and revenue, Stan and Pugh agree that becoming a mainstream part of the affiliate landscape will depend on a combination of regulatory clarity, continued consumer adoption and a commercial model that provides sustainable value for both operators and affiliates.
“Three things stand out,” Stan said. “Regulatory clarity at both federal and state level, which is being worked through now. Second, commercial terms that reflect the value of the user, which means CPA rates moving up from where they are. Finally, a full season of behavior to look at, so that everyone in the chain is pricing off evidence rather than expectation.
“Beyond that it is the ordinary work of a new vertical: product experiences built for the sports audience rather than for traders, and measurement that operators and affiliates trust equally.”
Pugh also highlighted three core points to consider moving forward: continued consumer adoption, regulatory clarity and a sustainable commercial ecosystem.
“If prediction platforms continue to attract users and demonstrate strong retention, then affiliates will naturally invest more resources into the category,” he said. “We also need to see the commercial side mature. Operators and affiliates need models that create sustainable value for both sides.
“If that happens alongside continued product innovation and greater consumer awareness, I see no reason why prediction markets cannot become an established part of the affiliate landscape.”
For affiliates, prediction markets represent an opportunity that is still taking shape. The audience is there, the product is expanding, and both Catena and Better Collective are already investing in the space, even at CPA levels below those of sportsbooks. If operators can prove customer value and, as Stan expects, more competitors enter the market, that gap should narrow, strengthening the case for prediction markets as a major new affiliate vertical.
