CFTC app interface over agency website background.
2–3 minutes

CFTC seeks to redefine ‘swap’ as courts split over Kalshi

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) sent two rules to the White House for review this week. Both would redefine “swap,” a term at the center of the fight over prediction markets jurisdiction.

The filings reached the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs on September 28. One, a proposed rule, would extend the definition to cover event contracts. The other, an interim final rule, would exclude casino-style gambling products. Neither is classified as economically significant. The agency hasn’t published the text of either.

The definition matters because swaps fall under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. Platforms cite that status to fend off state gambling regulators.

How swaps definition plays into ongoing court battle

The timing of the filings is notable. On September 25, the Sixth Circuit ruled unanimously that Kalshi hadn’t shown its sports contracts are swaps, letting Ohio and Tennessee apply state gambling laws. The court said the contracts don’t depend on events tied to a financial, economic or commercial consequence.

The Ninth Circuit reached a similar conclusion last month in a Nevada case. The Third Circuit went the other way in April, ruling 2-1 for Kalshi. The split points toward Supreme Court intervention.

Dodd-Frank lets the agency further define “swaps.” But since the Supreme Court’s 2024 Loper Bright decision, courts give agencies no automatic deference on statutory meaning. A new rule would be another argument for judges to weigh, not the final word.

Prediction markets reject casino gambling

The casino filing follows a June proposal from Chairman Michael Selig’s commission. That proposal suggested contracts on games of pure chance would likely be found contrary to the public interest. The Coalition for Prediction Markets, an industry group representing Kalshi, Crypto.com and others, has said it would back a ban on markets tied to slot machines and roulette.

An interim final rule takes effect without prior public comment, so the exclusion could arrive first.

Read together, the filings appear to draw a narrow federal lane. Sports and other event contracts would sit inside the swap definition; casino games would sit outside it. That would confine gambling-related prediction markets to sports, which the industry says carry informational value. It also tracks the industry’s own preferred definition of gaming.

The move may also carry a political aim. Eight states, including California and New York, now enforce statutory bans on dual-currency sweepstakes casinos. Keeping prediction markets away from slots and table games could help them avoid a similar backlash from lawmakers. The filings, however, include no stated rationale, and the agency hasn’t explained its motive.

Opponents are unlikely to be satisfied. The American Gaming Association says prediction markets offer gambling outside state and tribal regulatory frameworks. The Sixth Circuit said Kalshi’s sports contracts function, in practical terms, as sports bets. A federal definition may shape the argument, but the Supreme Court is likely to have the final say on whether a sports contract counts as a swap.