A judge’s gavel sits in front of an open book
5–7 minutes

Kalshi dealt court setbacks in Iowa, Utah over sports contracts

Kalshi suffered two court setbacks Tuesday in its widening fight with states over whether sports event contracts offered on federally regulated exchanges can be subject to state gambling laws.

In Iowa, U.S. District Judge Stephen Locher denied Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction, finding that the company is unlikely to succeed on its argument that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempts Iowa gambling laws. Separately, the Tenth Circuit rejected Kalshi’s emergency request to block Utah officials from taking enforcement action while the company appeals an earlier loss there.

The rulings came less than two weeks after the Ninth Circuit sided with Nevada in KalshiEX v. Assad, rejecting key parts of Kalshi’s preemption argument. Locher cited that Aug. 28 decision repeatedly in the Iowa ruling, while Utah submitted it to the Tenth Circuit as supplemental authority before Tuesday’s order.

The Ninth Circuit decision also sharpened a split with the Third Circuit, which ruled in Kalshi’s favor in its New Jersey case in April. New Jersey has since asked the Supreme Court to review that decision, arguing that states retain authority to regulate sports gambling even when contracts are offered through a Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)-regulated exchange.

New Jersey’s petition is now on the Supreme Court docket as No. 26-299, with Kalshi’s response due Oct. 8.

Iowa judge questions Kalshi’s preemption case

Locher’s 23-page ruling laid out why he found that Kalshi is unlikely to prove that federal commodities law prevents Iowa from regulating its sports contracts as gambling.

The judge focused on the purpose and language of the CEA as amended by Dodd-Frank. He wrote that Congress was primarily addressing financial derivatives used to manage existing economic risks, while Kalshi’s sports contracts serve a different purpose.

Citing the Ninth Circuit’s Aug. 28 ruling, Locher noted that Kalshi’s sports contracts “do not help institutions or investors hedge against risk; they create risk, largely for ordinary consumers, where none previously existed.”

Locher also pointed to the CEA’s treatment of “gaming,” which appears in a provision giving the CFTC authority to prohibit certain contracts involving gaming, terrorism, assassination and war.

He said there was a “high degree of irony” in Kalshi using that law to argue Congress intended to allow gambling free from state oversight when structured as a federally regulated contract.

“In a big picture sense, it is difficult to believe this is what Congress wanted,” Locher wrote.

Judge rejects Kalshi’s claims of irreparable harm

Locher also rejected Kalshi’s argument that it would suffer irreparable harm without an injunction. Kalshi said it has nearly 42,000 Iowa users with millions of dollars in open contracts and argued that operational changes needed to exclude the state could cost tens of millions of dollars annually.

But Locher called Kalshi’s filings “heavy on hyperbole” and said they offered little concrete information about the extent of the risk. He noted that Kalshi had promoted itself as offering legal sports betting nationwide and said the company should have anticipated that state regulators might consider its sports contracts gambling.

“To the extent it would be expensive in these circumstances for Kalshi to deploy new technology or change aspects of its business to ensure compliance with Iowa law, this is a problem of the company’s own making,” Locher wrote. “It should have proceeded with greater caution.”

Tenth Circuit leaves Utah free to pursue enforcement

The Utah setback was narrower but carries more immediate consequences. In a two-page order, the Tenth Circuit denied Kalshi’s emergency request for an injunction while it appeals an Aug. 4 ruling that found the CEA does not preempt Utah law.

The appeals court did not rule on the merits of Kalshi’s case or explain which part of the injunction standard the company failed to meet. It said only that Kalshi had not shown it was entitled to an injunction, considering factors including its likelihood of success on appeal and the risk of irreparable harm.

That leaves Utah officials without a federal appellate order preventing them from pursuing enforcement while the appeal continues. Unlike Iowa and many other states challenging prediction market sports contracts, Utah has not legalized sports betting and generally prohibits gambling.

In its emergency motion, Kalshi argued that complying with Utah law could conflict with its obligations as a federally regulated exchange and expose it to significant harm. Utah countered in its opposition that it is enforcing state anti-gambling laws, not trying to regulate derivatives, and noted that Kalshi already uses geofencing in Michigan, Nevada and Washington. 

The Tenth Circuit also had the Ninth Circuit’s Nevada ruling to consider. Utah submitted Assad as supplemental authority, while Kalshi filed a response arguing that the Ninth Circuit had misread the CEA. The Tenth Circuit’s order did not say whether that decision influenced its denial.

Supreme Court fight comes into focus

For now, the two rulings leave Kalshi without court protection from enforcement in either state. Utah can pursue enforcement under its anti-gambling laws while Kalshi’s appeal continues, and Iowa officials remain free to bring civil or criminal action after Locher declined to block enforcement.

Neither ruling itself requires Kalshi to immediately stop offering sports contracts in either state. But the growing patchwork of state cases is increasing the importance of a Supreme Court ruling that could more broadly decide whether states can apply their laws to federally regulated sports contracts.

With New Jersey’s petition now before the Supreme Court, gaming attorney Daniel Wallach says Kalshi’s next move in the Ninth Circuit could also be important. He noted Tuesday on X that Kalshi added additional Milbank attorneys to the Nevada case and said the additions could signal plans to seek en banc rehearing of the Aug. 28 decision. The deadline for such a request is Friday.

A rehearing petition would delay the Ninth Circuit’s mandate while the request is considered. Wallach also floated the possibility that Kalshi could pursue rehearing while another party to the Ninth Circuit cases, such as Robinhood or Crypto.com, asks the Supreme Court to review the decision, potentially putting both sides of the Third-Ninth Circuit split before the justices.

The Iowa and Utah rulings continued a run of state victories. By Wallach’s tally, states have now won 13 consecutive federal court rulings since a July 27 Minnesota decision favored Kalshi and the CFTC, and have prevailed in 36 of 42 rulings he tracks, an 86% success rate.

UPDATE: Kalshi filed a petition later Wednesday for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in the Ninth Circuit’s Nevada case, following the Aug. 28 ruling against the company. Milbank partner Josh Sterling, one of Kalshi’s attorneys, posted the filing on LinkedIn, saying the panel relied heavily on a CFTC rule that is being repealed and replaced and that the case “deserves a second look.”

The second part of the scenario Wallach outlined also materialized Wednesday, when Robinhood asked the Supreme Court to review the Ninth Circuit’s Aug. 28 ruling in a separate challenge to Nevada’s effort to apply state gaming laws to sports event contracts available to Robinhood customers.